Pages

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Dear Erotica: You Fight Like a Girl

Erotica and Romance Writers- I know you love tough guys. As a  reader- I love tough guys too! Rough and tumble, shoot-first-ask-questions-later Alpha males who take no prisoners are unquestionably HOT. I also know you also love kick ass chicks- ladies who stretch the term with their kick-ass-itude.






I just got one suggestion to you writers out there. Go shoot someone. Stab someone. PUNCH someone in the mouth. (Okay, my lawyer is telling me that I shouldn't say that sort of thing-- so replace all of the above someone s with something s or whatever leads you not to get put in jail).




My point is sometimes (read: a LOT of the time) it is painfully obvious that the writers of these bang-pow shoot-em-ups have never held a gun. Or, in the case of a lot of our UF or historical friends, a blade. And no body knows how to throw a punch. Dear friends-- if you are pulling fight choreography straight from a Buffy episode....oh. (BTW I love Buffy, but realistic fighting was not one of the high points)
I know that writers are supposed to live out of their imaginations, but for some things nothing can replace the reality of experience. Of course, I know not everyone has the stable of black-belts at their disposal. Or brothers who are Marine Vets. Or close friends who are ex- Special Forces. Maybe I should have a camp. What do you think? Do writers need experience?

3 comments:

  1. Due to a conversation I had with someone IRL I add this question... Should book violence be realistic? The other party to the conversation said that "Fantasy was better served if the violence was fantastical"

    I have (and had) a response but I wonder what others think first.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Honestly, I don't care that much whether it's truly realistic or not. I don't get carried away in the choreography because, for me, I'm always more concerned with the WHY of the fight and the relationships between the fighters. I just don't read fight scenes with much detailed thought.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi!
    I'm passing the Stylish Blogger Award to you...check out my site for rules on how to obtain it!
    Thanks!
    http://lacedlittlemuffin.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete

Thanks!